Silver
ETF May Cause Spike
Todd Stein & Steven McIntyre
The Texas Hedge Report
Jun 15, 2005
Courtesy of www.texashedge.com
Perhaps the biggest wild card
in the 2005-2006 timeframe for silver prices is the introduction
of the silver ETF and its success (or lack thereof). Since early
last year, silver bulls such as ourselves have been taken with
the notion of a silver ETF and its impact on the silver market.
Silver is such a small, tight, relatively illiquid market that
a successful innovation in the way for individuals and mutual
funds to own silver (without the hassles of storage costs
and steep premiums to spot) could have a pronounced effect on
the silver price.
The gold ETF was launched late
last year after a very long and frustrating battle with the SEC
to get the ETF registered and approved for trading. The belief
last year was that the powers that be in the silver industry
would follow the blueprint the World Gold Council laid out in
its ETF and that the silver ETF would have much smoother and
quicker sailing. So far the jury is out on smoother, but quicker
does not appear to be the case as a proposed silver ETF has not
even been filed with the SEC. Our sources have long indicated
that an oil ETF would be the next commodity ETF to get done,
then silver, copper, and a few others would likely follow. So
it was with great interest that these two headlines passed our
desks recently:
05-18-05 07:18
PM EST
NEW YORK -(Dow Jones)- Standard Asset Management, a company created
by Ameristock Funds, filed a registration statement with the
Securities and Exchange Commission to create an exchange-traded
fund that tracks the price of oil.
06-08-05 07:25
AM EST
LONDON -(Dow Jones)- Barclays Global Investors, a unit of U.K.-based
Barclays PLC (BARC.LN), will file an application for the first
silver exchange traded fund with the U.S. Securities and Exchange
Commission before the end of the year, a spokeswoman told Dow
Jones Newswires Wednesday.
So some progress is being made.
An oil ETF was actually filed with the SEC. And it appears that
Barclays is getting close to filing a registration statement
with the SEC for a silver ETF. A silver ETF trading in 2005 now
appears to be a long shot with 2006 being the more likely timeframe.
However, the ETF is closer to becoming a reality and its impact
on silver is likely to be far more pronounced than gold or oil.
How big an impact is anyone's guess.
The two U.S. gold ETFs (tickers:
GLD & IAU) have combined to gather a little around 6 million
ounces or about $2.6 billion in assets since November. These
ETFs have seen their assets steadily increase month after month
for the first 6 months despite a generally lower gold price.
If silver could muster annually just 1/10th of what gold did
in only 6 months, we are talking about $260 million in silver
ETF demand, which at a $7.20 silver price implies 36 million
ounces in incremental demand for silver. We will argue the effect
will likely be much more over time, but 36 million ounces seems
a conservative starting point. Below, we have hazarded a guess
based on annual gold demand versus gold U.S. ETFs size and what
their relationship in gold might mean in silver. We then applied
that to silver and tried to again come up with a conservative
estimate of the ounces a silver ETF may suck up. The shaded cells
are the estimates derived from our analysis. One can see how
a 46.4 million ounce estimate is finally arrived at:

Likewise, we are emboldened
on the silver ETF's chances for success in light of the huge
investment demand increase (34 million ounces) silver exhibited
in 2004 and the reports of continued demand in 2005. In fact,
early 2005 results for gold show increased demand in 2005, which
should bode well for silver. To quote from the World Gold Council
Q1 report (silver demand statistics are only available annually):
"The first quarter
of 2005 saw exceptionally strong demand for gold, particularly
from the jewelry sector, from bar and coin purchases and from
investment in gold backed exchange traded funds (ETFs). End-user
consumption (which includes all identifiable categories of demand)
was 26% higher in tonnage terms and 32% higher in dollar terms,
compared to the same period in 2004."
The stage seems set for a successful
silver ETF as investment demand for the metal is increasing thanks
to the Dollar and other fiat currencies' weaknesses, along with
tightening inventories.
more follows for subscribers
. . .
Jun 13, 2005
Todd Stein & Steven McIntyre
Archives
Texas Hedge Report
Todd Stein
& Steven McIntyre
email: admin@texashedge.com
For more information, go to http://www.texashedge.com.
Recent Gold/Silver/$$$ essays at 321gold:
Apr 04 Gold Stocks Strong As Stk Mkt Implodes Morris Hubbartt 321gold Apr 04 Gold Stocks Defy Markets Adam Hamilton 321gold Apr 02 The Dogs of War are Howling for Gold Bob Moriarty 321gold Apr 01 Tariffs & Supreme Currency Gold Stewart Thomson 321gold Mar 31 41st Anniversary of Eiffel Tower Flight Bob Moriarty 321gold Mar 30 Stk Mkt Carnage & Soaring Gold captainewave 321gold
|
321gold Inc
|