Silver
of the Sierra Madres, revisited
Bob Moriarty
Archives
May 15, 2006
In August of 2004, I visited
a silver mine in Mexico and did a
write up about a company. The company was Endeavour Silver and
the shares were $1.34 at the time. Today the stock is up 350%.
And going higher. It was a good call and recently I took the
opportunity to revisit the mine and the company.
Endeavour Silver
is one of those ultra-rare birds. It's an actual primary silver
producer. When I visited them two years ago they were processing
a silver/lead/zinc ore with a flotation circuit, and leaching
the high grade tailings in their cyanide circuit. Today they
are a pure silver producer. But with zinc up to $1.56 and lead
at $.56, one of the ideas Endeavour Silver Chairman and CEO Brad
Cooke is considering is opening a mine level containing a high
percentage of lead and zinc ore.
Two years ago,
in May of 2004, EDR signed a deal to acquire 100% of the producing
Santa Cruz silver/lead/zinc mine and the Guanacevi processing
plant for a total of $7 million US, spread over four years. Silver
was about $6 an ounce and it cost roughly $4.50 an ounce to mine
and mill it. It was a good move. Today silver is $14-ish an ounce
and Brad's costs have gone down a little to just over $4 an ounce
total costs. In a way, his silver mine is turning into the proverbial
"Gold Mine."
The Guanacevi
mining district is home to over 50 past producing silver mines
and in total has produced over 500 million ounces
of silver in 470 years of mining. At present only the Santa Cruz
mine of Endeavour and two other small mines are still in production.
But the area has a large and experienced pool of mining labor.
Once EDR completed
the final agreement with their Mexican partners in 2004, Brad
and his crew set out to determine how to upgrade the mill and
how to deliver more ore for processing. At that point he was
pretty much an exploration company trying to make it as a production
company. When you go to a gold show and ask some of the gold
"Gurus" about the wisdom of actually going into production,
they will hold up their fingers in the shape of a cross in order
to stop you from hexing them with such unorthodox theory. The
average "Gold Guru" doesn't even want to hear about
companies going into production.
The
"Gold Gurus" want the pure exploration plays and I
totally disagree. With these prices, if you aren't thinking about
production, you don't have a project, you have a swath of moose
pasture. We have $3.70 copper, $1.57 zinc, $.57 lead, silver's
over $14 and gold touched $700 for the first time in 26 years
just a few days ago.
Exploration
makes sense when you can't make money mining. But there are far
more projects out there than smart guys to run them. We have
been shutting down mines for 30 years and it's about damned time
we start opening some mines. Newmont and Barrick aren't going
to do it. The rewards and easy money to be made in this cycle
is going to be buying the shares of the juniors just going into
production. Heresay be damned.
Brad bit the
production bullet and he has made a wonderful transition into
becoming a full fledged operating mine and mill. He did it the
smart way, (and easy way), rather than hire and train his own
people, the mining is all contract mining. EDR will begin using
their own staff for some of the mining soon as part of a mine
optimization program.
Last year's
production was about equal to that of the last ten years in total.
The mill processed about 102,617 tons to produce just short of
a million ounces of silver. Mine operating costs were about $35
a ton and milling costs were about $23 a ton. Metal
recoveries in 2005 averaged 76.55 for gold and 74.8% for silver.
A cyanide circuit should be able to achieve higher recoveries
and Endeavour is in the midst of a major revamp of the crushing
circuit in order to achieve a finer grind and to obtain higher
recovery of both gold and silver.
The flotation
circuit has a present capacity of about 420 tpd and the cyanide
leach circuit is capable of about 800 tpd. Flotation is used
with the silver/lead/zinc ore and cyanide for the straight silver
oxide ore currently being mined. The mill has an operating staff
of about 90 people in addition to the 23 or so on the exploration
and mining side.
[click
on thumbnails to enlarge images]
 |
 |
 |
 |
The Endeavour Aliens |
The Traveling Hammer |
Light at the end of the tunnel |
Drill Core |
For 2006, EDR
envisions mining and milling about 195,000 tonnes of ore with
a grade averaging 450 grams of silver and about .61 gram of gold
per tonne. They anticipate production of about 2.0 to 2.2 million
ounces of silver and about 4,500 ounces of gold. The figures
they gave us anticipated a silver price of $8 and gold of $480
with a project cash flow of about $7 million based on a $4.50
all up cost per ounce of silver. Using today's real world prices,
you can double that figure and think $15 million US in cash flow
and be about right. Imagine that, a silver producer who makes
money. What will they think of next?
While I was
in Mexico on the tour, EDR announced the completion
of a $31 million dollar financing. With almost $40 million in the bank
they are well positioned for growth. Brad tells me that he intends
to be in the top five silver producers. I'd guess once Guanacevi
is optimized, it will top out production somewhere in the 5 million
ounces of silver range. That wouldn't put EDR in the top five
silver producers. So if they can't grow internally, don't be
real surprised if Brad goes out and does some external growth
through an acquisition. Do be real surprised if he doesn't.
 |
 |
 |
 |
Drill Core Store |
Cash Flow |
The Pour |
The Pour |
We don't own
any Endeavour Silver at the present time but we have owned it
and made a lot of money on it. I would look to reenter on any
significant correction. Brad has a top notch team in place with
the management depth to support being in the top five producers
and I would be really surprised if he doesn't make it up to the
top five within 3-4 years. Endeavour is an advertiser and as
such we are biased, you are responsible for your own investment
decisions.
I've not said
this before even though it's been on my mind. Brad Cooke pioneered
the model of exploration/production in Mexico and now ten or
more juniors have copied him. Especially after the thrashing
the Bolivian based silver stocks have taken, investors need to
wake up to the fact that Mexico is one of the best mining countries
in the world in terms of political stability, quality of mines
in both ore grade, and quantity of mining districts. And the
Mexican miners are among the best in the world. Mexican based
Canadian juniors should be selling at a real premium to the rest
of the market.
 |
 |
 |
 |
Brad Cooke |
Where there's muck there's silver |
Lots of Balls |
Dinner at the beach |
By the time
you read this I will be on yet another long trip. To Brazil and
Argentina with a 2-3 day break in the middle visiting Uruguay.
Back for a few hours at home in Miami and then I'm straight off
to Ontario. I will return at the end of May and the staff would
appreciate it if you didn't send me emails until May 29th.
Endeavour Silver Corp
EDR-T $4.70 Canadian (May 12, 2006)
37.9 million shares outstanding
Endeavour Silver website
Bob Moriarty
President: 321gold
Archives
321gold Inc

|